What Does Safety Even Feel Like?

First Steps Toward Healing After Betrayal

What Does Safety Even Feel Like? First Steps Toward Healing After Betrayal

Elliott Kemmet, MSW, BSW, RSW

Founder of My Restored Roots & Lead Therapist

A Quiet Opening

You've already made it through the most intense moments of discovery. You've survived the initial shock when you first realized something was deeply wrong—the moment when your world felt as if it had suddenly tilted off its axis. You've lived through those overwhelming early days and sleepless nights, the ones spent anxiously searching for clues, scrolling through messages, or listening for any suspicious sounds. During that time, every notification or swipe on your partner's phone might have seemed unbearably loud, even louder than your own heartbeat.

Now, thankfully, that intense storm has begun to subside. The crisis itself has faded, and you're no longer consumed by the frantic, desperate need for answers. Yet, despite this quieting, things still don't feel settled. Even though the immediate threat has diminished, you're still aware of a lingering unease, almost like a quiet alarm still ringing faintly in the background. You might feel a tension or restlessness, as if danger is still lurking, even though you can't quite pinpoint why.

In this quieter moment, a single, stubborn question might keep surfacing within you: "What does safety even feel like anymore?" Perhaps you used to know clearly what safety meant: a predictable routine, honesty in conversations, or simply knowing exactly where your partner was and what they were doing. But now, after everything that's happened, safety might feel elusive, foreign, or even impossible. It's completely normal for this question to tug at your chest, making you wonder if you'll ever truly feel secure again.

If you're feeling uncertain about safety or questioning whether trust can ever truly be restored, you are not lost or stuck. You're exactly where most people find themselves during the gradual journey toward healing. Recovery from betrayal trauma isn't a straight line or a neatly packaged plan with quick solutions. Instead, it's a slow, gentle process of noticing, observing, and gradually rediscovering your sense of security.

This reflection isn't intended to offer you an instant solution or five easy steps to quickly "move on" from your experience. It's also not designed to pressure you into forcing feelings that aren't yet genuine. Instead, it's simply an invitation to slow down and notice what's happening inside you. Allow yourself to pay attention to your body and breath, noticing any tension or anxiety gently, without judgment or pressure. As you begin to notice these feelings, consider also inviting the gentle presence of God into these moments. Even if faith feels distant or abstract right now, the quiet assurance of God’s presence can gently begin to remind you that security doesn't require immediate solutions or visible progress.

Safety and trust can be slowly rebuilt even when things don't yet appear fully resolved. You don't need perfect circumstances or absolute certainty to begin experiencing moments of genuine security. It can happen softly, in small increments, as you learn to trust your own feelings and intuition again, and as you sense that you are not alone. Over time, these subtle shifts and moments of noticing begin to accumulate, allowing you to feel a sense of calm and steadiness—even before all your questions are answered.

What Is Safety After a Storm?

First, let's clearly define what safety is not. Safety is not the assurance that everything is perfectly fine or that all problems have disappeared. It isn't simply believing or feeling that "things are okay now." Safety also isn't just the fact that the harmful behavior or situation has finally stopped. While that is certainly an important milestone, the cessation of harm alone doesn't instantly translate into a sense of safety. Safety doesn't mean you've fully recovered or "gotten over" the painful experiences you've endured. Healing and recovery take significant time and effort, and feeling completely "over it" is a later stage, not the initial experience of safety.

True safety often arrives much earlier in your healing journey, sometimes even while the aftermath of the trauma or difficulty is still very much present and actively felt. Real safety is more immediate and can be experienced even when the emotional and psychological pain still lingers. It's that initial moment of relief when you realize there's nothing you need to do or prove just to take a full, deep breath. It's the experience of not feeling as if you must constantly earn your peace or justify your right to rest.

Safety is about creating or finding a space—emotionally, physically, spiritually—where your nervous system is allowed to pause and release tension, even if it's only for a brief moment. It's that brief period of relaxation when your body is not bracing for another emotional blow, criticism, or harm. Even if this relaxation lasts only a few seconds, it's an essential step toward rebuilding your sense of security and peace.

Safety also involves hearing a voice—whether it's God's voice, a friend's comforting words, or your own inner compassionate dialogue—that doesn't rush you or push you to move past your pain prematurely. It's about having the freedom and support to linger in your grief or discomfort without judgment or impatience.

Imagine standing beneath a large, protective tree right after a heavy rainfall. The ground underfoot is soft, muddy, and unstable. The sky above remains cloudy, signaling that the storm isn't completely gone. Yet, standing beneath the branches of this sturdy tree, you feel a distinct sense of calm and quiet. The storm hasn't disappeared entirely, but it is momentarily held back, offering you a brief respite. This brief moment allows you to ease the tension in your jaw and shoulders, to breathe without fear. This temporary calm is exactly the kind of initial safety we are aiming for. It's the very first step in learning how to truly feel safe again.

The Body Remembers — And It’s Tired

Even after the vivid details of the screenshots have faded from your memory, your body continues to bear the impact of what you've experienced. You may find your jaw perpetually tight, as if you're clenching it with enough force to bite through wire. Your stomach might remain constantly tense, feeling twisted like a garden hose that's been tightly coiled and forgotten. Your heart may race unexpectedly, even during quiet moments, such as when you're sipping calming chamomile tea, leaving you confused and unsettled by your own physical responses.

In many ways, your body has become a battlefield long after the actual conflict has ceased. The lingering impact can manifest as intrusive memories that feel like sharp fragments of shrapnel, embedding themselves unexpectedly into your awareness. Ordinary daily activities can suddenly transform into hidden landmines, triggering emotional responses that catch you off guard. Stress hormones like cortisol linger in your system, creating an invisible fog of anxiety that permeates every aspect of your physical and emotional well-being. It's completely understandable if you feel perplexed and exhausted by everyday tasks—something as simple as running errands at the grocery store might leave you drained and in need of rest.

It’s important to recognize that not every physical sensation you experience during this time needs to be fully trusted or acted upon immediately. Your body's reactions are not signs of weakness or failure; rather, they are normal responses to significant stress and trauma. Your body is diligently trying to process and heal from the emotional wounds it has endured. Instead of judging or pushing away these sensations, you can gently acknowledge them, offering yourself compassion and patience.

Think of your relationship with your body as one of friendship and gentle companionship. Sit with your body as you might sit beside a friend who is exhausted, offering quiet support without expectation or pressure. One helpful practice is to place a palm softly over your sternum, noticing the gentle, steady rhythm of your heartbeat beneath your hand. Each subtle thud against your ribcage serves as a reassuring reminder that despite the chaos and confusion, life continues, and your body remains resilient and determined to carry you through to recovery.

Breath Is the Beginning

Scripture recounts that on the evening of Jesus’ resurrection, He appeared to His disciples and greeted them with peace. John 20:22 specifically says, “He breathed on them and said, ‘Peace be with you.’” Before giving His disciples instructions or sending them on a mission, He offered them breath—a gentle exhale symbolizing calmness and reassurance. This peace was not presented as a task or duty, but rather as a fundamental and comforting experience.

Breathing can be a powerful tool in managing stress and anxiety, particularly in moments of emotional upheaval like betrayal trauma. It serves as a grounding practice that reconnects you to your physical body and the present moment. Unlike structured commands or rigorous exercises, the peace Jesus imparted was effortless and natural, mirroring the innate rhythm of breath itself.

Allow yourself to engage in this gentle breathing exercise to anchor yourself:

Begin by comfortably sitting or standing, whatever feels most natural. Slowly inhale through your nose, silently counting to four. Notice the breath gently rising within you. Hold your breath briefly at the peak, then slowly exhale through slightly parted lips, extending the exhale to a count of six. Observe the breath descending and releasing tension from your body. Allow your shoulders to relax slightly, sinking downward by even the smallest measurement.

Notice this subtle relaxation as a meaningful sign—a gentle resistance to stress and chaos. It is a quiet affirmation that the same Creator who initially breathed life into humanity continues to sustain your every breath, even in difficult times. This breathing practice is gentle, adaptable, and intentionally trauma-informed, designed specifically for individuals navigating betrayal trauma.

If the suggested breathing cycle feels too lengthy or uncomfortable, feel free to shorten the counts. Adjusting the timing of your breath doesn't diminish its effectiveness; rather, it emphasizes the importance of comfort and presence over performance or perfection. Your objective is simply to be present, fully experiencing the natural rhythm of your breathing without forcing or straining.

This method is compassionate and respectful of the complexity of your trauma, prioritizing safety, gentleness, and personal pacing. The focus is on feeling your breath as a natural, soothing rhythm rather than attempting to control, shape, or impose judgment upon it. Each breath cycle serves as a reminder of your connection to your Creator, who remains close even when life's circumstances feel overwhelming or chaotic.

You Are Not Meant to Do This Alone

God intentionally designed the process of healing to reflect His own relational and communal nature. Just as God exists in relationship—Father, Son, and Holy Spirit—our healing journey mirrors this interconnectedness through the concept of co-regulation. This involves connecting body to body and spirit to Spirit. We were not created to manage pain or heal in isolation. Rather, our recovery is deeply enhanced when we are in meaningful relationships with others and with God.

Consider the sparrow, a small bird that does not keep itself warm by flapping its wings more vigorously or desperately striving on its own. Instead, the sparrow naturally seeks the warmth and protection of a flock. Similarly, humans thrive and recover best in community, where mutual support and shared presence provide comfort and strength.

With this understanding in mind, we created The Rooted Collective. This is an intentionally designed virtual space—a safe, welcoming environment specifically for wives experiencing betrayal. Here, women can gather without rushing or pressure, spending time together in calm reflection and gentle encouragement. Participants engage with Scripture in an embodied way, such as breathing slowly and meditatively through Psalm 23, reminding themselves gently, "He makes me lie down," emphasizing rest and peace rather than continuous striving or hustling.

In this supportive circle, participants gain steadiness not only from their own inner strength but also by borrowing the calm presence and reassurance from others. In these moments, members alternate roles: when one person needs rest, others keep watch, offering security and vigilance. This collaborative support enables each woman to safely close her eyes, knowing that others are there to maintain vigilance and provide emotional support.

Whether you choose to join The Rooted Collective or simply lean on a single trustworthy friend, it's important to recognize and remember that nervous systems and emotional wounds heal most effectively in the presence of others. Healing is not an isolated activity but a communal experience. As Scripture beautifully illustrates in Ecclesiastes 4:9-10 (paraphrased), "Two are better than one because if one falls, the other can help her stand again." Together, we become stronger, steadier, and more resilient, sharing both the burdens and the journey toward restoration.

Explore Our Dedicated Recovery &

Rebuilding Services

Explore our targeted counseling and workshops, designed to rebuild trust and foster healthier relationships after the challenges posed by secret website use

Want a Companion for the First Steps?

If today's insights stirred something within you, there's so much more waiting.

I've created a full 60-minute deep dive masterclass on this very topic, thoughtfully crafted to guide you from overwhelm to clarity, and from confusion to a deeper sense of purpose and peace.

You'll find this transformative masterclass—and so much more—inside The Rooted Collective Membership.

It's your space for powerful growth, connection, and healing, with exclusive content, live office hours (ask me anything), downloadable resources, and a vibrant community of support.

Curious? You can dive in today for just $1 on a trial, binge the masterclass,

and soak in all the additional insights, tools, and encouragement.

Don't walk this journey alone. Click below and step into deeper roots and greater growth:

Frequently Asked Questions

Is emotional numbness after betrayal trauma normal?

Yes. Numbness is a common response to overwhelm. When your nervous system can’t process the intensity of pain all at once, it protects you by temporarily shutting down feelings.

Why can’t I feel God even though I’m praying?

Spiritual silence in this season doesn’t mean God is absent. You may be in what Scripture calls a “wilderness” season—a quiet but sacred space where God is still present, holding you even when you feel nothing.

Am I falling behind if I don’t feel strong or spiritual?

Not at all. Many women find themselves in this emotional “middle space.” Healing isn’t linear, and not feeling anything doesn’t mean you aren’t healing—it means your body and soul are stabilizing.

What helps when I feel stuck in this numb phase?

Start gently. Breathe deeply. Journal what you can’t feel. Listen to calming worship music. Create structure through grounding routines. Trust that God honors even the smallest movements toward healing.

Where can I get support if I feel alone in this?

You’re invited to join the Rooted Collective Membership, where you’ll find trauma-informed guidance, safe community, and encouragement—even if you’re in a season of silence or emotional shutdown.

Still have questions?

Find answers to more common questions [here]